Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Bones & Chews Bully Stick at Chewy.com
"Uses an all-natural beef recipe that dogs will adore."
Best for Puppies: Pet's Choice Naturals Bully Sticks at Chewy.com
"They're high in protein and low in fat, plus they're free of preservatives."
Best for Large Dogs: Pawstruck Straight Bully Sticks at Amazon
"These bully sticks are longer which makes them a great picks for larger dogs."
Best for Small Dogs: Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks at Amazon
"They’re pencil-thin, making them the perfect size for toy and small breeds."
Best Odor-Free: Best For My Pets 12-Inch Bully Sticks at Amazon
"All of the flavor and nutritional value—but none of the smell."
Best Premium: Jack And Pup Premium Grade Bully Sticks at Amazon
"More expensive than other brands, but they’re worth it for the quality and taste."
Best Braided: 12" Braided Bully Sticks for Dogs at Amazon
"If you’ve got a world-class chewer in the house, these treats are built to last."
Best Variety Pack: Pawstruck Bully Stick Variety Pack for Dogs
"This variety pack includes seven different, equally delicious styles."
01 of 08
Best Overall: Bones & Chews Bully Stick 6" Dog Treats
For an all-around great bully stick, we love these 6” treats from Bones & Chews. It uses an all-natural, all-beef recipe that dogs will adore—and just as important, it’s 100% digestible. The treat works to clean your dog’s teeth and gums as they chew, and is suited to dogs of all ages, from puppies to seniors. They can be purchased in volumes ranging from a single stick to a case of 100, eliminating the need for frequent orders if your dog takes to them.
Customers love that these bully sticks last for hours and are free of jagged edges, alleviating fears of choking during consumption. They’re especially good for aggressive chewers—so if you’ve lost a favorite set of sneakers or two to your dog’s jaws, a purchase may be in order.
02 of 08
Best for Puppies: Pet's Choice Naturals Bully Sticks 6" Dog Treats
These bully sticks from Pet’s Choice are great for dogs of all sizes, from the smallest puppies on up through the biggest breeds. They’re made of 100% grass-fed beef, are high in protein and low in fat, with flavor locked in during the production process (they’re dried instead of dehydrated). They’re also free of preservatives and chemicals and are low in odor. They can be purchased in sizes from bags of six up to a 50-count.
Customers say these bully sticks last longer than other products, and while the lengths may vary slightly from bag to bag, they’ll usually be comparable in thickness. The sticks are also individually wrapped, which helps cut done on the smell factor if you toss one in your bag on the way to the park.
03 of 08
Best for Large Dogs: Pawstruck 12" Straight Bully Sticks for Dogs
Pawstruck’s 12” bully sticks are longer than some of our other options, making them a great picks for large dogs who need a little more bite for their buck. They’re made of all-natural beef and free of artificial ingredients, chemicals and hormones. As your dog chews, the stick works to remove plaque and tartar from their teeth, leaving them with a fresh smile and happy taste buds. They’re also highly digestible and have an impressive shelf life of 36 months.
These Pawstruck bully sticks can be purchased in sizes ranging from 10 sticks to 250, and customers say they’ve gotten rave reviews from their resident pooches. If you’ve got a large breed, these long-lasting sticks are sure to keep your dog occupied for hours.
04 of 08
Best for Small Dogs: Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks 5-6"
If your dog is on the smaller side, you won’t want a product that’s too big for their tiny jaws. Instead, go with a bully stick that’s on the thin end, like these ones from Nature Gnaws. Like the larger varieties, they’re made using all-natural ingredients and are naturally grain free, protein-rich and highly digestible. Best of all, they’re pencil-thin, making them the perfect size for toy and small breeds in need of a chewy treat.
Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks come 25 to a bag, and customers say they’re a hit with small dogs (and have saved countless chairs and table-legs from destruction). Just bear in mind that since they’re thinner than other varieties, they won’t last as long—and keep watch while they’re being enjoyed to make sure the thin sticks don’t splinter.Continue to 5 of 8 below.
05 of 08
Best Odor-Free: Best For My Pets 12-Inch Bully Sticks
If bully sticks have one drawback, it’s that the accompanying odor can be less than pleasant. Fortunately, there’s a solve for this with Best for My Pets’ odor-free bully sticks, which have all of the flavor and nutritional value of a regular bully stick—but none of the smell. These 100% digestible, low-fat treats add protein to your dog’s diet while promoting oral health. And while the manufacturer has somehow managed to eliminate that yucky odor, they’ve kept the recipe chemical, hormone and additive-free.
Customers express their amazement at this product’s truth-in-advertising: As described on the bag, they really are odorless. Additionally, a portion of each purchase goes to support dog rescues across the country, so both you and your pup will feel good about having these sticks in the house. The number of 12” sticks varies per bag based on size, but customers say it tends to hover between six and eight.
06 of 08
Best Premium: Jack And Pup 12-inch Premium Grade Odor Free Thick Bully Sticks
While your dog might not be the most discerning customer, you always want to be sure you’re giving your pet a high-quality product. There’s no question of that with Jack and Pup’s premium-grade bully sticks, each of which is handpicked and inspected at the brand’s USDA human-grade certified facility (not that you’d likely want to try one yourself). Made from free-range, hormone and antibiotic-free cattle, it’s careful preparation ensures each stick is safe from bacteria and other contaminants while they’re boiled, roasted, smoked and dried.
Customers say these treats are a little more expensive than other brands, but they’re worth it for the quality that’s baked into the product (and don’t worry, their dogs agree). The sticks do tend to vary in size a bit, so some supervision may be necessary if you’re giving your dog one that’s on the thin side. Expect to find around 10 sticks per bag—but if you think you’ve been shorted, the brand gets a callout for its winning customer service.
07 of 08
Best Braided: 12" Braided Bully Sticks for Dogs
If you’ve got a world-class chewer in the house, it’s time to break out the big guns with one of these braided bully sticks. Made by twisting three sticks together, these treats are built to last, often taking dogs whole days, not minutes, to gnaw through. Like other bully sticks, they’re 100% beef and chemical-free, and leave your dog’s teeth clean by breaking down plaque and tartar. They can be purchased in bags containing up to 250 sticks.
Customers say these bully sticks are perfect for dogs with a regular urge to chew, often proving to be the perfect, long-lasting distraction. The curved design is also effective for cleaning gums, working its way into the nooks and crannies inside your dog’s mouth more than a typical straight stick.
08 of 08
Best Variety Pack: Pawstruck Bully Stick Variety Pack for Dogs
Got a few dogs in the house with different chewing needs, but want to get your bully stick shopping done in one fell swoop? Go with a variety pack. This one from Pawstruck includes seven different, equally delicious styles: 5" and 7" straight sticks, a 7" braided stick, a bully stick ring, spring, and barbell—along with a filled esophagi (yum!). It’s a great way to test-drive a few different types of bully sticks and find the one that’s best suited to your pup—or simply keep a bit of variety in their life.
Each stick is all-natural and easily digested, and customers rave about the overall quality and value. The brand also offers a unique set for small breeds, which features a different mix of sticks made with pint-sized chewers in mind.
Our writers spent 4 hours researching the most popular bully sticks on the market. Before making their final recommendations, they considered 30 different bully sticks overall, screened options from 20 different brands and manufacturers, read over 50 user reviews (both positive and negative) and tested 1 of the bully sticks with their pet. All of this research adds up to recommendations you can trust.