Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best Overall: LupinePet Dog Collar at Amazon
"While strong, large breeds may benefit from a collar over one-inch, a ¾-inch width works for nearly every dog."
Best for Large Dogs: EzyDog Neo Classic Collar at Chewy
"A sturdy, secure collar is a must-have for larger, heavier dogs with a lot of strength."
Best Leather: Soft Touch Leather Collar at Amazon
"Despite its bargain price, the Soft Touch looks far more expensive than it is, and even comes with a lifetime warranty."
Best Runner-Up: Kurgo Muck Collar Waterproof Dog Collar at Amazon
"The Kurgo Muck collar is a great choice for active pups who spend most of their time rolling around in mud and jumping in lakes."
Best for Small Dogs: Pupteck Basic Nylon Dog Collar at Amazon
"Small dogs will benefit from a thinner, but still durable collar that will stay secure on smaller necks without the added bulk."
Best for Puppies: Pawtitas Dog Collar at Amazon
"The Pawtitas soft training collar is ideal for growing pups who could benefit from a more gentle grip."
Best for Pulling: PetSafe Gentle Leader Collar at Amazon
"It’s meant to curb excessive pulling, tugging, and barking, and it is only used while your dog is learning the right way to walk on a leash."
Best Overall: LupinePet Dog Collar
Dogs come in many shapes and sizes, so finding a perfect collar fit can be difficult. But the Lupine ¾" adjustable collar is the perfect size for nearly every dog. While strong, large breeds may benefit from a collar over one-inch, a ¾-inch width works for nearly every dog. The Lupine beats out the competition for best collar because it’s easy on the wallet, has a lifetime warranty against wear (including chewing!) and each size adjusts up to 10 inches, which is great if your dog tends to shed weight during warmer months.
We are partial to the “rain song” design, but the Lupine comes in over 18 different styles — so your whole canine brood can have different patterns. Reviewers say it is long lasting, durable and true-to-size, making it a great low-cost choice for nearly every dog.
Best for Large Dogs: EzyDog Neo Classic Collar
A sturdy, secure collar is a must-have for larger, heavier dogs with a lot of strength. The EzyDog Neo Classic Collar is 1 ¾ inches wide, which is only suitable for large necks (think Labrador or bigger) and made from rubber-like, non-porous neoprene that’s durable enough for extremely active dogs. It comes in four sizes (large through xxx-large) and four different colors.
Reviewers say the collar does a great job of distributing weight and won’t choke strong dogs during walks. They also rave about the material, stating that the neoprene stays clean and odor-free.
Best Leather: Soft Touch Leather Collar
Leather collars are long lasting, durable and attractive. If you’re ready to upgrade your nylon or rubber collar to a stylish leather version, the Soft Touch collar beats out its competition. Despite its budget price, the Soft Touch looks far more expensive than it is, and even comes with a lifetime warranty. It’s made from real leather with brass rings and comes in four sizes, though we recommend leather collars mostly for larger pups with wider necks. Since leather collars are meant to be less flexible and slightly harder, you’ll want to make sure your dog isn’t sensitive to collars before trying a leather version.
Owners rave about how attractive the Soft Touch leather collar is, saying it looks spiffy in any setting. If you want to give your pup a bit of well-made luxury, the Soft Touch is the perfect leather dog collar.
Best Runner-Up: Kurgo Muck Collar Waterproof Dog Collar
The Kurgo Muck collar is a great choice for active pups who spend most of their time rolling around in mud and jumping in lakes. It’s made from PVC-free plastic-coated nylon that’s flexible and waterproof, making it easy to wipe clean after a day of messy adventure. It comes in three sizes, ranging from 10" to 25" We love the fun patterns, and with nine different choices you’re sure to find a style that fits your dog’s personality. The Kurgo collar even comes with a bottle opener, which you’ll appreciate next time you’re on a long hike with your furry friend, but be aware that owners say it sticks out a bit.
Reviewers add that it’s easy to size the collar to individual dogs, and claim it has no smell after years of wear. If you’re looking for a collar for an active pup, the Kurgo Muck is a great choice.
Best for Small Dogs: Pupteck Basic Nylon Dog Collar
Small dogs will benefit from a thinner, but still durable collar that will stay secure on smaller necks without the added bulk. The Pupteck nylon collar comes in XS and Small, which ranges from 7" to 16" long and only 2/5"to 3/5", which is ideal for very small necks. It comes in six simple but attractive colors, and reviewers say the nylon material is long lasting. This collar won’t hold up to excessive pulling, but if your pup is more lap dog than the sporting type, it’s a great choice. Owners also state it fits tiny pups when other brands missed the mark.
Best for Puppies: Pawtitas Dog Collar
The Pawtitas soft training collar is ideal for growing pups who could benefit from a more gentle grip. Made from thin, soft nylon, the Pawtitas is extremely flexible and comes in four sizes. Puppies, especially those in the early training stages, may not need the bulk and strength of a larger collar, and the Pawtitas is a great way to keep them safe without getting in their way. The 13 colors also come with a reflective strip that is designed to reflect ambient light at night or in low-light conditions.
Owners note that you should add a few centimeters to the length to adjust for growing pups.
Best for Pulling: PetSafe Gentle Leader Collar
If your well-meaning pup drags you down the street every time you go for a walk, the Pet Safe Gentle Leader collar is a safe way to curb their pulling habit. While a harness may be better for some pulling pups, it’s important to find a solution that works for your specific pet — and a gentle leader is a great training tool for many dogs. It’s meant to curb excessive pulling, tugging, and barking, and it is only used while your dog is learning the right way to walk on a leash. It comes in five sizes and eight colors, and includes a training video to help owners learn the best way to use a leader.
The PetSafe leader has many enthusiastic fans that claim it’s the first product that made their walks more pleasant. It’s also a great choice for fearful or aggressive dogs; owners say it helps them easily control lunging and barking. We love the PetSafe Gentle Leader because it’s effective without rubbing or chafing, and utilizes a two-loop design (looping around the neck and the nose), which allows for maximum control with very strong dogs. The PetSafe leader is a great training collar that will provide a much more pleasant walking experience.
Our writers spent 900 hours researching and testing the most popular dog collars on the market. All of this research adds up to recommendations you can trust.
Fit The most important quality you want in a dog collar is a good fit—one that doesn’t slip off and isn’t uncomfortably tight or heavy. When shopping, take note of the collar's material—if it stretches, for example—as well as if it's adjustable.
Design Dog collars are designed with different purposes in mind, so it's helpful to know what you need before you start shopping. For example, you may want a basic collar that can hold dog tags and attach to a leash, or you may want one that can help correct behavior or provide a bit more support if your dog is particularly active.
Style Since a collar is likely the only accessory your pooch will wear every day, some people like to put a lot of thought into picking one that looks just right. The good news is that today, there are more choices than ever—collars come in a variety of materials, colors, and patterns.