Covering poop is a normal cat behavior, right? Not necessarily.
Wildcats that bury their excrement do so for basically two reasons: One is to keep their presence unknown from possible predators. The other is to show that they are not challenging more dominant cats. These more dominant cats rarely bury feces, and often leave waste on grassy tussocks that elevate and make it even more prominent.
So, it seems the only reason for a domesticated cat to bury her poop is if there is a dominant cat in the house. However, it is a very natural cat behavior. So why is your cat not doing it?
Humans have encouraged the behavior in our pet cats, by selectively choosing (and breeding) the ones that are “clean.” Cats that leave their excrement uncovered for the world to admire are not abnormal—they’re just being cats.
If your kitty has always dug-and-covered as normal litter box behavior, and suddenly makes a statement with uncovered poop, ask yourself what else has changed? This may be the cat’s way of sending a smelly signal to other cats (or even a stray hanging around outside the window) that the territory is owned.
Declaring "Their" Territory
In the wild, dominant cats (including jaguars, leopards, lions, and tigers) that are competing for territory don't bury their feces, sending a message that they are declaring that spot at theirs. So a domesticated cat may choose not to bury their poop to let other cats—or their owner—know "I am here." Even if a cat has lived in the same place for a while, he may not feel it is his territory. The smell of their poop shows that particular cat's presence.
Doing What Comes Naturally
Cats that choose not to cover, or leave a deposit outside the box, may simply be doing what comes naturally. Although burying feces is generally a modeled behavior from mamma cat, some cats actually never learn to do this. If they never watched their parent in the litter box, they may not know what to do.
In fact, one study followed female pet cats out and about, and observed them poop 58 times—and only twice did the cats try to dig a hole first, or cover it afterward. Roaming kitties may use unburied waste as another form of marking.
The Wrong Litter Box
When it comes to litter boxes, size does matter. Maybe your cat's litter box is too small for her to turn around inside the box to bury her poop. And, as the saying goes, cats can be finicky—perhaps she doesn't like the feel of the cat litter, or the box is too dirty, and would rather not spend any extra time in there. If you suspect one or both of these things could be true, give a new brand of litter a try, or upgrade to a larger sized litter box.
Possible Medical Issues
There aren't any specific diagnoses that would cause your cat to not bury their poop, but if your cat is experiencing some kind of pain—whether in their paws, while going to the bathroom, or just in general—that could deter them from spending more time in the litter box. Also, cats who have been declawed recently could choose to skip the burying process.