Hay Substitutes

When hay becomes scarce it often leaves horse owners scrambling to keep their horses healthy and well fed. Any number of natural disasters can affect the growth of hay fields. In most areas of North America, farmers are able to harvest two hay crops per season. Some areas may even be able to get a third 'cut'. Drought, late springs, floods and other disasters can mean the growth will be sparser and the cuts will be fewer. Less hay means not only is it harder to find, but it will cost...MORE more per bale. Horse owners may have to ship hay in from other areas, and that too can add to the cost and take more time to source and transport.

If a horse does not get enough bulk fodder, it may cause problems like ulcers (EGUS) and colic. Horses are grazers who spend most of their time chewing, so they may nibble on wood fences, stall partitions, or trees to satisfy the need. It's recommended that at very minimum a horse should eat 1% of it's body weight in fodder. Ideally, a horse should eat 2-2.5% of its weight in good quality fodder--hay or grass.​

Horses need the bulk fiber of hay to stay healthy. Although they can eat grain, they still need a forage substitute that provides the +20% fiber content that good pasture or hay provides. There are a few things that you can feed horses as a substitute for hay. Whatever you decide to feed, it's important to start feeding any of these fodder substitutes gradually and carefully monitor your horse's condition.

  • 01 of 08

    Beet Pulp

    Beet Pulp Pelts
    Image: K. Blocksdorf

    Beet pulp is a by-product of the sugar beet and is often fed to horses. Many horse owners notice that when they feed beet pulp,  horses eat less hay. Feeding beet pulp is easy and it can be fed dry or wet. In hot weather, wet beet pulp can sour and in cold weather, freeze to the feed tub. Beet pulps contain fiber, calcium, protein but no vitamins. Beet pulp can be fed in combination with hay or other fodders and a complete concentrate.

  • 02 of 08

    Straw

    straw
    lucentius/E+/Getty Images

    If you read books about horse care in bygone times, you might be aware that straw was commonly fed to horses. You may have a horse that is quite happy to munch on its straw bedding. Most of us view straw as bedding only. Straw is the stalks of harvested grains. Since the plant has come to the end of its life cycle, it has no nutrition.

    Used in combination with a concentrate that provides ample nutrition that includes mineral, vitamins, and proteins, oat straw can give horses something to graze...MORE on. Rye straw may carry a fungus that can affect mares in foal. Wheat and barley straw are less appealing to horses. Youngsters or seniors may not be able to digest straw easily.

  • 03 of 08

    Hay Cubes

    Hay Cubes
    Image: K. Blocksdorf

    Hay cubes may be an alternative to bales. Grass and legume hay are dried and chopped and pressed into cubes. The downside of hay cubes is that there is an increased chance of choke if they are fed dry and they don't fulfill the horse's need to chew. Since hay cubes tend to be expensive, they could be used in combination with poorer quality hay.

  • 04 of 08

    Silage, Ensilage or Haylage

    Feeding Silage, ensilage, or haylage is popular in some areas, but it does come with risks. The benefit to farmers is that it can be bagged at about 45% moisture, so it can be harvested in damp conditions. Since it isn't dry, it's beneficial to feed horses because there is no dust—good for horses with COPD and other respiratory problems.

    The downside of silage or haylage is that there is a chance of botulism poisoning. Handling can be tricky because the bag must not be punctured during...MORE storage. If you plan to feed haylage, ensilage or silage you should have your horse vaccinated for botulism before you start feeding this fodder.

    Continue to 5 of 8 below.
  • 05 of 08

    Concentrates

    pelleted feed
    Image: 2007 K. Blocksdorf

    Concentrates, available in many forms, can ensure that your horse is getting the nutrition it needs and makes up for any shortfalls in the fodder you may need to feed. There are a lot of different forms and vitamin/mineral/protein/fiber combinations, so you'll need to examine the labels and match the concentrate to your horse's needs. Feeding concentrates by themselves is not recommended. Your horse will still need a source of fiber.

  • 06 of 08

    Alfalfa

    Often, legumes like alfalfa will grow in conditions that grass won't grow in. Since alfalfa is high in calcium, it's important to make sure the horse is getting concentrates or supplements that balance its diet. Alfalfa should be fed in combination with grass hay.

  • 07 of 08

    Old Hay

    hay bale. Image: 2005 K. Blocksdorf

    Yes, you can use hay from previous years as long as it has been kept clean and dry. The nutritional content will decline over time, but that can easily be made up with concentrates. Testing is the best way to figure out how to make up for any shortfalls.

  • 08 of 08

    Don't Feed

    Brans, including wheat and rice bran, are not recommended as major part of your horse's diet. All can cause mineral imbalances. Don't be tempted to throw lawn clippings, garden refuse or compostables over the fence. All can contain plants toxic to horses.