Ear cropping (or trimming) is an elective cosmetic surgical procedure that involves cutting and shaping the floppy part of a dog’s ear (the ear pinna). This is done so the ear stands up and creates a look or standard for some dog breeds. The professional and social view of ear cropping has changed over the years, as has the legality of the procedure in some countries.
How Is Ear Cropping Done?
Under general anesthesia, the floppy part of the ear is cut in a precise shape. The surgery should only be done by a licensed veterinarian and experience with this procedure would be beneficial. Puppies are usually six to 12 weeks old when their ears are cropped.
In order for the ears to heal in the desired upright precision after surgery, they must be “posted” to a hard surface and taped until completely healed. Bandages need to be changed weekly, typically. The entire process can last from 4-8 weeks.
Dog Breeds With Cropped Ears
There are numerous breeds of dogs that can sport cropped ears. Usually, these breeds have a standard look that is part of the breed’s history.
One common reason given in support of the ability to have a dog’s ears cropped is to preserve traditional purebred standards.
Is Ear Cropping Right or Wrong?
Ear cropping is a topic that crosses many different groups that are involved with dogs, from breeders to veterinarians, and those who show dogs to animal rights activists. There are varied opinions on this subject, most of which are subjective.
The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) policy is that they "oppose ear cropping and tail docking of dogs when done solely for cosmetic purposes." Their policy has been in place since 1999 and was affirmed as recently as 2012 when the AVMA added that they “encourage the elimination of ear cropping and tail docking from breed standards”. (AMVA, nd)
However, the American Kennel Club (AKC) "recognizes that ear cropping, tail docking, and dewclaw removal, as described in certain breed standards, are acceptable practices integral to defining and preserving the breed character and enhancing good health." They emphasize that dogs with natural ears are not prohibited from entering dog shows. More and more “natural” dogs are being successfully shown, according to a Westminster spokesperson. (Pagan, pets.webmd)
Ear cropping is banned in the United Kingdom and Australia and in many European countries. Animal rights activists consider this procedure to be unnecessary and a violation of an animal’s rights. Those who support the practice tout breed preservation, breed standards, and health concerns as reasons to allow the procedure to remain an owner’s decision. (Goldman, NAIA)
Risks of Ear Cropping
As with any surgical procedure, there are risks involved. Normal concerns with using anesthesia on animals as well as the possibility of post-surgical complications are included in the risks. Cropped ears can become infected, continue bleeding, cause the animal pain from sensitivity or phantom pain, and the success of surgery is never a guarantee. In some extreme cases, the dog’s cropped ears could become so infected, amputation is needed which comes with an entirely separate list of complications.
Benefits of Ear Cropping
Although the prevention of ear infections (Canine Otitis Externa) is often cited as a benefit of ear cropping, there is no research data that supports that claim. On the contrary, the AMVA states that hanging ears on a dog does not increase the likelihood of ear infections. Also, there are no breeds that have shown a propensity for ear infections over other breeds. The likely explanation for what may seem like a clustered similarity in breed has more to do with the physiological aspects of an individual dog’s ear shape than the breed itself. (AMVA, policies)
Should I Have my Dog’s Ears Cropped?
This is a decision that each owner has the responsibility to make for their dog. You should consider very carefully the risks versus the benefits of ear cropping for your personal experience.
What is the reason you want to crop your dog’s ears? Is it cosmetic or is it for health reasons? Your veterinary is a good source of information and assistance for either reason. Your vet can explain what, if any, health benefits would come from cropping your dog’s ears. Also, they can explain the procedure, the risks, and what your dog will have to experience for the surgery and healing.
Cosmetic reasons for ear cropping are not widely necessary for showing dogs, or even for breeding dogs. Research the fields you and your dog will be involved in to determine if this surgery is even needed. It is definitely an additional expense and health risk from the surgery. The healing process will require time and attention on your part and multiple veterinary visits to ensure proper care of the cropped ears.
Being an informed pet owner and consulting with an experienced and trusted vet will allow you to make the best decision for your dog.
Riemer, Stefanie et al. The Predictive Value Of Early Behavioural Assessments In Pet Dogs – A Longitudinal Study From Neonates To Adults. Plos ONE, vol 9, no. 7, 2014, p. e101237. Public Library Of Science (Plos), doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0101237
Ear Cropping And Tail Docking Of Dogs. American Veterinary Medical Association, 2020
Welfare Implications Of Ear Cropping-Dogs. American Veterinary Medical Association, 2020